The fluorine dichotomy Amphibole control on fluorine availability during magmatic differentiation

Main Article Content

Jackson S. Borchardt
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6891-3314
Cin-Ty Lee

Abstract

Experimental and observational evidence suggests that water and fluorine (F) are incompatible in silicate minerals and originate from similar sources in the mantle. This, in turn, suggests that F and water should coevolve in magmatic systems. However, hydrous subduction zone (“arc”) magmas are depleted in F relative to anhydrous magmas. We explore this apparent dichotomy in fluorine’s behavior by examining amphibole, which preferentially incorporates F into its crystal structure. By developing a parametrized fluorine amphibole/silicate melt partition coefficient for F, we show that F concentrations in calculated equilibrium melts in arc systems do not increase with differentiation. This indicates that F behaves compatibly in hydrous arc magmas due to sequestration in amphibole-bearing arc cumulates. In dry magmatic systems, where amphibole does not crystallize, we show that F behaves incompatibly during differentiation, resulting in F enrichment in evolved magmas. These results have implications for the formation of ore deposits associated with elements that complex with F, such as rare-earth elements.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Borchardt, J. S. and Lee, C.-T. (2026) “The fluorine dichotomy: Amphibole control on fluorine availability during magmatic differentiation”, Volcanica, 9(2), pp. 705–716. doi: 10.30909/vol/lvhp7808.
Section
Articles
Citation information
Crossref
This article has citations in Scopus
Link to article page on Google Scholar
Connected papers
Dates
Received 2025-08-04
Accepted 2026-07-29
Published 2026-08-24
Alternative metrics via Dimensions and altmetric

Metrics


Smart Citations via scite_